«FIVE STEPS TO PLANNING SUCCESS. EXPERIMENTAL EVIDENCE FROM U.S. HOUSEHOLDS Aileen Heinberg, Angela Hung, Arie Kapteyn, Annamaria Lusardi, Anya ...»
VI. Discussion and Future Work In this paper, we designed and evaluated a financial education program that demonstrably increased participants’ objective knowledge and self-efficacy. Importantly, our field experiment approach allowed us to conclude that the improvements we saw in the treatment groups were caused by the Five Steps program or by the particular format tested. Our results show that given the very minimal time respondents spent watching the videos or reading the narratives (each of the videos or narratives takes about three minutes), Five Steps has sizable short-run effects on objective measures of respondent knowledge. Moreover, keeping informative content relatively
constant, format has significant effects on other psychological levers of behavioral change:
effects on motivation and self-efficacy are significantly higher when videos are used, which ultimately influence knowledge acquisition.
It is important to reiterate that the experiment at this stage measures only outcomes related to objective knowledge and self-efficacy. The focus group discussions suggest that in general, the written narratives may promote knowledge retention but videos may more strongly motivate action and behavior change; this remains a possibility to be tested in future work. Ultimately, the goal of this study is to examine effects on behavior, with outcomes to be collected in a follow-up survey. Empirical findings suggest that self-efficacy and behavior are related, although the causal relationships are not well-established: measures of self-efficacy have been found to be correlated with health behavior (e.g., Kreuter et al., 1999; Strecher et al., 1986; Gillis, 1993; Holden, 1991) as well as in other domains (Stajkovic and Luthans, 1998), including finance (Gutter, Copur, and Garrison, 2009). There is some evidence that suggests financial education programs can increase financial self-efficacy, and ultimately behavioral change (e.g., Sanders et al., 2007; Shockey and Seiling, 2004).
In general, the program presented is an example of how field experiments can contribute to better understanding of the effectiveness of financial literacy interventions. As noted in the introduction, part of the reason for the mixed results in related work is the lack of rigorous evaluation. Field experiments are an ideal policy tool for gaining causal inference in this, as well as in other domains. Future work should focus on using field experiments to investigate which components of educational interventions are most effective.
Armstrong, April W., Nayla Z. Idriss, and Randie H. Kim (2011), “Effects of video-based, online education on behavioral and knowledge outcomes in sunscreen use: a randomized controlled trial.” Patient Education and Counseling 83(2): 273–277.Ashraf, Nava, Dean Karlan, and Wesley Yin (2009), “Female
Impact of a commitment savings product in the Phillipines.” World Development 38: 333–344.
Bandura, Albert (1989), “Human agency in social cognitive theory.” American Psychologist, 44(9): 1175–1184.
Bayer, Patrick, Douglas Bernheim and John Karl Sholz (2009), “The effects of financial education in the workplace: Evidence from a survey of employers.” Economic Inquiry, 47(4): 605–624 Benartzi, Shlomo, and Richard H. Thaler (2001), “Naive diversification strategies in retirement saving plans.” American Economic Review, 91(1): 79–98.
Benartzi, Shlomo, and Richard H. Thaler (2004), “Save More
Using behavioral economics to increase employee savings.” Journal of Political Economy 112.1, Part 2, pp. S164–S187.
Benartzi, Shlomo, and Richard H. Thaler (2007), “Heuristics and biases in
retirement savings behavior.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 21(3):
Bernheim, B. Douglas, and Daniel M. Garrett (2003), “The effects of financial education in the
evidence from a survey of households.” Journal of Public Economics 87(7): 1487–1519.
Bernheim, B. Douglas, Daniel M. Garrett, and Dean M. Maki (2001), “Education and saving: The long-term effects of high school financial curriculum mandates.” Journal of Public Economics 80(3): 435–465.
Bertrand Marianne, Dean Karlan, Sendhil Mullainathan, Eldar Shafir and Jonathan Zinman (2010), "What’s advertising content worth?
Evidence from a consumer credit marketing field experiment,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 125: 263-305 Bruner, Jerome (1987), “Life as narrative.” Social Research 54(1): 11–32.
Campbell, John (2006), “Household finance,” Journal of Finance 61, pp.1553– 1604.
Choi, James J., David Laibson, and Brigitte C. Madrian.
(2005), “$100 Bills on the
Suboptimal Saving in 401(k) Savings Plans.” NBER Working Paper 11554.
Clark and D’Ambrosio (2008), Adjusting retirement goals and saving behavior The role of financial education in A. Lusardi (ed.). Overcoming the Saving Slump: How to Increase the Effectiveness of Financial Education and Saving Programs, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 237-256.
Congdon, William, Jeffrey R. Kling, and Sendhil Mullainathan (2009), “Behavioral economics and tax policy.” National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper No. 15328.
Davidhizar, Ruth, and Giny Lonser (2003), “Storytelling as a teaching technique.” Nurse Educator 28(5): 217–221.
Delavande, Adeline, Susann Rohwedder, and Robert Willis (2008), Preparation for retirement, financial knowledge and cognitive resources. MRRC Working Paper Series 190.
Duflo, Esther, and Emmanuel Saez (2003), The role of information and social interactions in retirement plan decisions: Evidence from a randomized experiment. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 118: 815-842.
Frederick, Shane, George Loewenstein, and Ted O’Donoghue (2002).
“Time discounting and time preference: a critical review.” Journal of Economic Literature. 40: 351-401.
Gagliano, M. E. (1988), “A literature review on the efficacy of video in patient education.” Academic Medicine 63(10): 785–792.Gillis, Angela (1993), “Determinants of a health-promoting lifestyle: An integrative Review,” Journal of Advanced Nursing 18: 345–353.
Gist, Marilyn E. (1989), “The influence of training method on self- efficacy and idea generation among managers.” Personnel Psychology 42(4): 787–805.
Green, M. C., and T. C. Brock (2000), “The role of transportation in the persuasiveness of public narratives.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 79(5): 701–721.Gutter, Michael, Zeynep Copur, and Selena Garrison (2009), “Which Students are More Likely to Experience Financial Socialization Opportunities? Exploring the Relationship Between Financial Behaviors and Financial Well-Being of College Students.” Networks Financial Institute Working Paper 2009-WP: 07.
Holden, Gary (1991), “The relationship of self-efficacy appraisals to subsequent health related outcomes: A meta- analysis,” Social Work in Health Care 16: 53–93.
Hung, Angela A., Andrew M.
Parker, and Joanne K.
Yoong (2009), “Defining and measuring financial literacy.” RAND Working Paper, no.
Hung, Angela A., Erik Meijer, Kata Mihaly, and Joanne K. Yoong (2009), “Building Up, Spending Down: Financial Literacy, Retirement Savings Management, and Decumulation.” RAND Working Paper No. WR-712.
Jeste, D. V., L. B. Dunn, D. P. Folsom, and D. Zisook (2008), “Multimedia educational aids for improving consumer knowledge about illness management and treatment decisions: a review of randomized controlled trials.” Journal of Psychiatric Research 42(1): 1–21.Kozma, Robert (1991).
“Learning with Media,” Review of Educational Research Summer 61(2): 179–211.
Kreuter et al., (1999), M. W., Strecher, V. J., & Glassman, B. (1999), One size does not fit all: the case for tailoring print materials. Annals of behavioral medicine, 21(4): 276-283.
Lusardi, Annamaria (1999), “Information, Expectations, and Savings for Retirement,” in Henry Aaron (ed.), Behavioral Dimensions of Retirement Economics, Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution Press and Russell Sage Foundation, 81–115.
Lusardi, Annamaria (2008), “Financial
An Essential Tool for Informed Consumer Choice?” Working Paper, Joint Center for Housing Studies, Harvard University.
Lusardi, Annamaria, (2009), “U.S. Household Savings Behavior: The Role of Financial Literacy, Information and Financial Education Programs,” in C.
Foote, L. Goette, and S. Meier (eds.), Policymaking Insights from Behavioral Economics, Federal Reserve Bank of Boston, 109–149.
Lusardi, Annamaria (2010), “Americans’ Financial Capability,” mimeo, Dartmouth College.
Lusardi, Annamaria (2012), Numeracy, Financial Literacy, and Financial Decision-Making,” Numeracy, 5(1), Article 2, January 2012.
Lusardi, Annamaria and Jason Beeler (2007), “Saving Between
The Role of Planning,” in B.
Mitchell, and B.
Soldo (eds.), Redefining Retirement: How Will Boomers Fare? Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2007, pp. 271–295.
Lusardi, Annamaria, Pierre-Carl Michaud, and Olivia S. Mitchell (2013), Optimal Financial Literacy and Wealth Inequality. NBER Working Paper 18669.
Lusardi, Annamaria, and Olivia S.
Mitchell (2007), “Baby Boomer Retirement
The Role of Planning, Financial Literacy, and Housing Wealth,” Journal of Monetary Economics 54: 205–224.
Lusardi, Annamaria, and Olivia Mitchell (2008), “Planning and Financial Literacy.
How Do Women Fare?”
American Economic Review, 98(2):
Lusardi, Annamaria, and Olivia Mitchell (2009), “How Ordinary Consumers Make Complex Economic Decisions: Financial Literacy and Retirement Readiness,” NBER Working Paper n. 15350.
Lusardi, A., and O. S. Mitchell (2011a).
“Financial Literacy and
Implications for Retirement Wellbeing.” In Financial Literacy: Implications for Retirement Security and the Financial Marketplace, O. S. Mitchell and A. Lusardi (eds.).
Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, 2011: 17–39 Lusardi, Annamaria, and Olivia S. Mitchell (2011b).
“Financial Literacy and Retirement Planning in the United States.”
Journal of Pension Economics and Finance 10:
Lusardi, Annamaria, and Olivia S. Mitchell (2014).
“The Economic Importance of Financial
Theory and Evidence.” Journal of Economic Literature 52(1): 5–44 Lusardi, Annamaria, Olivia Mitchell, and Vilsa Curto (2010), “Financial Literacy Among the Young,” Journal of Consumer Affairs, 44(2): 358–380.
Lusardi, Annamaria, and Peter Tufano (2009a), “Debt Literacy, Financial Experiences, and Overindebtedness,” NBER Working Paper n.
Lusardi, Annamaria, and Peter Tufano (2009b), “Teach Workers about the Peril of Debt,” Harvard Business Review, November, pp. 22–24.
McDaniel, M. A., P. J. Waddill, and P. S. Shakesby (1996), “Study strategies, interest, and learning from text: The application of material appropriate processing.” In D. Hermann, C. McEvoy, C. Hertzog, P. Hertel, and M.
Johnson (Eds.), Basic and applied memory research: Theory in context.
vol. 1 (pp. 385–397). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
Meier Stephan and Charles Sprenger (2013), Discounting financial literacy: Time preferences and participation in financial education programs, Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 95: 159–174.
Michielutte, Robert, Judy Bahnson, Mark B. Dignan, and Elissa M. Schroeder (1992), “The use of illustrations and narrative text style to improve readability of a health education brochure.” Journal of Cancer Education 7(3): 251–260.
Norris, Stephen P., Sandra M. Guilbert, Martha L. Smith, Shahram Hakimelahi, and Linda M. Phillips (2005), “A theoretical framework for narrative explanation in science.” Science Education 89(4): 535–563.
Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (2005), Improving Financial Literacy: Analysis of Issues and Policies, Paris, France.
Purcell, Kristen (2010). The State of Online Video. Pew Internet & American Life Project.
Sanders, C. K., T. L. Weaver, and M. Schnabel (2007), “Economic Education for Battered Women: An Evaluation of Outcomes.” Affilia 22(3): 240–254.
Shafir, Eldar, Peter Diamond, and Amos Tversky (1997), “Money Illusion,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, CXII(2): 341–374.
Shampanier, Kristina, Nina Mazar, and Dan Ariely (2007), “Zero as a Special
The True Value of Free Products.” Marketing Science 26(6): 742– 757.
Shockey, Susan S., and Sharon B. Seiling (2004), “Moving into
Application of the transtheoretical model of behavior change to financial education.” Financial Counseling and Planning 15(1): 41–52.
Stajkovic, Alexander, and Fred Luthans (1998), “Self-efficacy and work-related performance: A metaanalysis,” Psychological Bulletin 124: 240–261.
Stango, Victor, and Jonathan Zinman (2009), “Exponential Growth Bias and Household Finance,” Journal of Finance 64: 2807–2849.
Strecher, V. J., B. M. DeVellis, M. H. Becker, and I. M. Rosenstock (1986), “The role of self-efficacy in achieving health behavior change.” Health Education & Behavior 13(1): 73–92.
Yoong, Joanne (2011), “Financial illiteracy and stock market
Evidence from the RAND American Life Panel,” in
Implications for Retirement Security and the Financial Marketplace, edited by O. S. Mitchell and A. Lusardi, Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK: pp. 76–100.
Table 1: Percentage of correct responses to each question at baseline by gender, age, income, and education (Y0).