FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Abstracts, online materials

Pages:     | 1 || 3 | 4 |   ...   | 7 |

«Work, care and life among low-paid migrant workers in London: towards a migrant ethic of care November 2006 Kavita Datta, Cathy McIlwaine, Yara ...»

-- [ Page 2 ] --

So, for example, many Black and minority ethnic women in Northern economies are engaged in relations of care outside of their own families, which in turn, has potentially adverse implications on their ability (or perceived ability) to care for their own families. This is exacerbated further when women are physically separated from their families, which is often the case for migrants who leave immediate and extended kin behind in their home countries. Gender and ethnicity/race also strongly mediate citizenship rights and therefore access to state support and welfare benefits which in turn define and shape racial and ethnic differences in the sphere of social reproduction (Cox and Watts, 2002; Mattingly, 2001). Similarly gender and ethnicity and race are very important in determining who does what. For example, not only is care work dominated by women, there is often a hierarchy of preference for particular ethnic groups such that women of a particular nationality may be most sought after as housemaids and cooks (Cox and Watts, 2002; Stiell and England, 1999). Highlighting more subtle differences based on ethnicity and race, Duffy’s (2005) work in the USA illustrates that while white women dominate in nurturing care work (which is better paid and professional), Hispanic women perform mainly non-nurturing reproductive work such as food preparation and cleaning while Black women are generally over-represented in both nurturing and reproductive labour (see also Nakano Glenn, 1991).

Research on the interactions between care, caring and space has been critical in providing more nuanced understandings of these relationships which move beyond the ‘caring’ and ‘careless’ dichotomy while also highlighting the complex negotiations of trust, disclosure and vulnerability that are central to the giving and receiving of care (Conradson, 2003; Dyck, 2005). Dyck et al’s (2005) work has explored how the meaning of home changes in the case of elderly people as it is transformed into a place both of rest but also of work.2 The emotional labour involved in the creation of caring spaces is particularly evident in these accounts as exemplified by relations of trust, loyalty, affection and love (McDowell, 2005). Furthermore, the provision of care is the outcome of complex relationships and interactions between the household, the economy and the state. This is evidenced by the fact that the restructuring of care provision in many industrialised nations associated with welfare cuts and the intensification of the work ethic determines who gets cared for, where they receive care as well as from whom (Dyck, 2005; Kofman, 2006). As Stahaeli and Brown (2003) point out, not only has welfare reform recast the relationship between families, citizens, communities and the state, it has firmly positioned the individual/families as being responsible for their own well-being.

Another critical dimension of this research has been the focus on the way in which caring relations are stretched across space as evidenced by the emergence of ‘global circuits of care’ (Anderson, 2000; Ehrenreich and Hochschild, 2002; Yeates, 2004, 2005). As noted above, these ‘circuits’ are crucially shaped by, and reflect, global inequalities, such that increasing numbers of poor migrants from the Global South cannot live with their families and support them at the same time (Ehrenreich and Hochschild, 2002). This research has been part of a wider approach to understanding the feminisation of transnational migration that has developed a more holistic understanding of gender as an integral component permeating all migration processes at various scales whether the individual, family, state or labour market (Donato et al., 2006; HondagneuSotelo, 2001; Pessar, 2005).

In turn, research which considers the intersections of transnational migration and circuits of care has highlighted the following key themes. For a start, there is a recurring debate concerning the extent to which migration should be viewed as empowering or exploitative for women (Hondagneu-Sotelo, 1999; Mahler and Pessar, 2006; Pessar and Mahler, 2003). While early research highlighted the emancipatory potential of migration for women, more recent work has been more tempered and has highlighted a range of exploitative dimensions, noting the connections between changes in gender ideologies and differing employment histories, family and state structures and practices (Mahler 1999; Menjívar 1999), class positions and (especially) ethnicity (Willis and Yeoh 2000). Referring to it as the “female underside of globalisation”, Ehrenreich and Hochschild’s (2002, p. 3), research illustrates the extent to which the global feminisation of labour has continued to restrict women to a narrow range of heavily gendered occupations typified by low-paid service jobs such as caring, cleaning and food processing (Bullock, 1994; McDowell, 2004). Potentially, then, migration and employment may not be empowering processes and this may be further exacerbated by dominant native gender ideologies which may remain one step behind economic realities. As such, even while it may be necessary for women to migrate so that they can provide for their children and their families, gender conventions may continue to preach that they stay at home to care for their children. Their migration may be interpreted as being tantamount to the abandonment of their children, notwithstanding that most women make provisions for their children’s care (Parreñas, 2002; Zontini, 2004). In turn, women migrants often feel great anxiety at this separation from their children and such moves are rarely undertaken lightly (Aranda, 2003; Yeoh and Huang, 2000).

Linked with this, new social institutions have emerged, such as the ‘transnational family’ (Yeoh, Huang and Lam 2005), which demand a rethinking of hegemonic feminine and masculine identities, the nature of caring and care giving as well as the intersections between the family, the economy and the state. The focus of much research has been on transnational mothering (Parreñas 2005; Hondagneu-Sotelo and Avila 1997) and the extent to which this constitutes a ‘care drain’ at home. There is evidence that while the migration of mothers may lead to some reconstitution of gender caring roles in that women take on the role of breadwinner, it does not necessarily lead to a reshaping of male gendered roles as women’s caring work is displaced onto the shoulders of other female kin, namely grandmothers, daughters and aunts (and usually in that order) (Schmalzbauer, 2004). Furthermore, both transnational mothering and the emergence of dual-wage earner families has implications for the children who are left behind (Hochschild, 2002; Parreñas, 2005).

Hochschild (2002) illustrates the extent to which some of these children undergo emotional deprivation as love and affection is diverted away from them to the richer children in the Global North. At the same time, migrant women endeavour to nurture from afar through telephones, remittances and gifts if not visits (Parreñas, 2002). Yet, ironically, where circuits of care and affection are effectively maintained (itself dependent upon where the migrant is, what type of job they are engaged in), pressures on men to assume care giving responsibilities are generally absent.

While male involvement in caring is more variegated than presented above (Gerstel and Gallagher, 2001; McIlwaine et al., 2006; Dyck, 2005), Hochschild (2002) posits that greater male involvement might depend upon raising the value of care work which leads to a lateral as opposed to horizontal displacement of caring activities when mothers start to work. At a larger scale, there is also an appreciation of the fact that migration may potentially constitute not only a ‘brain drain’ but also a ‘care drain’ whether we measure this in terms of skilled professionals such as nurses or doctors or, at the lower end of the skills spectrum, home carers, au pairs and so on (Hochschild, 2002; Kofman and Raghuram, 2006).

Feminist researchers have also explored the implications of global circuits of care on feminist solidarity. Ehrenreich and Hochschild (2002) posit that it brings ambitious and independent women together – and often in very close proximity to each other in the home (see also Mattingly 2001).

Yet, they argue that it does not do this in a way in which second-wave feminists would have wanted, in solidarity, as ‘sisters’ or allies, but instead at best, as employer and employee, or at worst, mistress and maid. Migrant women are doing work that has been completely devalued because it is what women, then ‘women of colour,’ and more recently, migrant women have done.

They are a source of cheap labour which in turn perpetuates the low status of the labour involved.

Parrenãs (2001) argues that migrant women are themselves often only ‘partial citizens’ and have significantly different access to material resources and citizenship rights compared with native women (see also Dyck, 2005). Yet, they potentially enable native women to enjoy fuller social citizenship which is increasingly linked to work and production (Kofman, 2006).

At the same time, implicit in the narratives of many migrant women is a negative judgement of Northern women, and society in general, who abandon their children and elderly into the care of strangers so that they can pursue careers (see below). In practice, both sets of women are caught in a bigger game whose rules they have not written – one of global inequality in which wages earned as a nanny abroad outstrip those of a middle-class professional in one’s own country, in which the gap between the rich and poorer nations is widening without any signs of change leading to people looking for private solutions to public problems, and in which two wages are often needed to maintain a household in the contemporary world (Hochschild, 2002). The stretching of social relations and everyday life over space through transnational migration means that the meaning of care is reconstructed and being mediated through local and global economic and social processes Indeed, as Dyck (2005) argues, a glimpse into the everyday gives us an insight not only into the local, but increasingly to processes being played out at a much wider scale.

More recently, researchers have begun to argue that the wealth of information that exists on global circuits of care has been largely observed at the micro-level of the household and needs to be integrated with broader arguments on the welfare state; immigration policies and so on. Kofman (2006) states that there is little explicit acknowledgment of the fact that migrants make vital contributions to the maintenance of welfare regimes and that despite popular perceptions of migrants as benefit scroungers, they are also providers of care. The role of the state in creating a demand and a supply for care workers must also be acknowledged (ibid.; Yeates, 2005) Furthermore immigration policies fundamentally shape the care-work balance and strategies that migrants are able to provide for their own families. Part of this initiative to link what is happening at the household level to broader economic and social processes can be achieved by focusing on both paid and unpaid work. This leads us to the second aim of this paper: namely how do migrants combine paid and unpaid caring work, how does this impact upon their own work-care-life balance and contribute to a distinct migrant ethic of care?

The recent interest in the work-life balance is attributable to a variety of factors. For a start there is an appreciation that the ‘24/7’ global economy has created a demand for a flexible labour force prepared to work long hours (Hochschild 2003; Houston 2005; McDowell 2004; Taylor 2002). The increased participation of women with dependent children in the labour market, as well as an increase in lone parents, has also led to a concern about the work-life balance given the gendering of caring responsibilities and activities. Indeed, women appear to bear many of the costs of poor work-life balances given that their greater participation in productive work has not generally been matched by men’s assumption of more domestic and reproductive responsibilities leading to a double or even triple workload for women (see above, also Hochschild 2003; Ungerson and Yeandle 2005).

It is important to highlight some of the shortcomings of existing research. As observed above, the term ‘work-life’ is rather euphemistic in that the focus has often been on productive and reproductive work. As such, the fact that ‘life’ should be made up of both personal and care time has often not been the explicit focus of research although it is vital for an ethic of care which recognises the importance of the self as well as others (Yeandle, 2001). Furthermore, given the focus of research on caring or reproductive work, there is a concomitant lack of research on the impact of work on the right of individuals to engage in a variety of activities (leisure, educational), as well as voluntary and community life and political organisation (Bradley et al. 2005). It is also hard, as Taylor (2002) argues, difficult to exactly identify what constitutes a ‘balance’ between work and life. Finally, and perhaps most pertinent in this context, as Hochschild (2003) argues the work-care-life balance is strongly mediated by class such that it is the middle classes which strive for it by employing strategies which predominantly involve other women, an important and increasing number of whom are migrant women. Where the work-care-life balance of migrants has been considered, it has been from the productive-reproductive nexus and as illustrated above, often focusing on the caring arrangements that transnational mothers make for their own children. There is far less research on the arrangements that they are able to make once their children move with them or are born after migration. Arguably, migrants are often placed in a difficult position as they may lack the resources to purchase good quality childcare, have little recourse to the public provision of care,3 while their mobility has also separated them from extended family who may have been able to provide care for them at home (although see Wall and José, 2004).

After a brief methodological note, the paper turns to consider our own empirical research on the paid and unpaid care work provided by migrant men and women in London.

Pages:     | 1 || 3 | 4 |   ...   | 7 |

Similar works:

«BSPED Recommended Guideline for the Management of Children and Young People under the age of 18 years with Diabetic Ketoacidosis 2015 These guidelines for the management of DKA in children and young people under the age of 18 years are based on the NICE guideline for Type 1 and Type 2 diabetes in children and young people [published August 2015, recommendations 1.4.1 to 1.4.66]. During the development of the NICE guideline the evidence for the diagnosis, investigation and management of DKA was...»

«Archived version from NCDOCKS Institutional Repository http://libres.uncg.edu/ir/asu/ The Learning Outcomes of Mentoring Library Science Students in Virtual World Reference: A Case Study GERALDINE PURPUR and JON LEVI MORRIS Abstract: This article reports on the cognitive and affective development of students being mentored in virtual reference interview skills by professional librarians. The authors present a case study which examines the impact on student learning resulting from librarian...»

«15c2-12(b)(1), but is subject to revision, amendment and completion in a final Official Statement. Under no circumstances shall this Preliminary Official Statement constitute an offer to sell or the This Preliminary Official Statement has been prepared for submission to prospective bidders for the bonds herein described and is in a form deemed final by the Corporation for purposes of SEC Rule solicitation of an offer to buy, nor shall there be any sale of the bonds in any jurisdiction in which...»

«Congressional attitudes CSIS RepoRt on the Future oF the u.s.–south Korea relationship A Report of the International Security Program Center for Strategic and International Studies Project Director Derek J. Mitchell Author Jason W. Forrester May 2007 Congressional attitudes on the Future oF the u.s.–south Korea relationship A Report of the International Security Program Center for Strategic and International Studies Project Director Derek J. Mitchell Author Jason W. Forrester May 2007 About...»

«Knight Templar Magazine Index The Knight Templar magazine was first published in 1955 on a bi-monthly, subscription basis. This official organ of the Grand Encampment of Knights Templar became a monthly publication in 1961, and in July 1969, the Grand Encampment began all-member mailings. Also beginning in 1969, pages 28 and 29 were devoted to the news of the individual state. Later, the grand jurisdictions used pages 16 and 17 for state supplements, and late in 2008, pages 18 and 19 were used...»

«Enclosure 1 List of Additional Uncompleted ITAAC Items Included in the Pilot Project Enclosure 1 23-Feb-16 COL Index Subject Page No. No. 28 Uncompleted ITAAC 1 29 Uncompleted ITAAC 3 450 Uncompleted ITAAC 5 513 Uncompleted ITAAC 7 853 Uncompleted ITAAC E. 9 Enclosure 2 Completion Plans for Uncompleted ITAAC Items Listed in Enclosure 1 Enclosure 2 23-Feb-16 Subject: Uncompleted ITAAC [Index No. 28] ITAAC Statement Design...»

«Paper P7 (SGP) Professional Level – Options Module Advanced Audit and Assurance (Singapore) Monday 1 June 2015 Time allowed Reading and planning: 15 minutes Writing: 3 hours This paper is divided into two sections: Section A – BOTH questions are compulsory and MUST be attempted Section B – TWO questions ONLY to be attempted Do NOT open this paper until instructed by the supervisor. During reading and planning time only the question paper may be annotated. You must NOT write in your answer...»

«Report No. 37379-GLB Beyond Corporate Social Responsibility: The Scope for Corporate Investment in Community Driven Development December 21, 2006 Social Development Department Sustainable Development Network Document of the World Bank ©2006 The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development / The World Bank 1818 H Street NW Washington DC 20433 Telephone: 202-473-1000 Internet: www.worldbank.org E-mail: feedback@worldbank.org All rights reserved This volume is a product of the staff of...»

«Medieval Church: Roman Catholic Sacraments Randy Broberg Grace Bible Church 1439 AD Seven Sacraments Affirmed Officially Sacrament 1: Baptism: Immersion Baptisteries Although there is ample evidence of river baptisms, soon the baptisms were elaborate rituals conducted in a “baptistry” which was near to but separate from the church building. A Baptistry Interior Quite early in the Middle Ages the water came to be viewed as “holy water” and prayers were offered to sanctify it. Immersion...»

«latina/chicana mothering edited by Dorsía Smith Silva toronto, canada table of contents Acknowledgments xi Introduction: Conceptualizing Latina/Chicana Mothering Dorsía Smith Silva I: Telling Our Tales: Testimonios Are Hunters Born or Made? Ana Castillo My Mother’s Memory Mayra Santos-Febres How (In a Time of Trouble) I Discovered My Mom and Learned to Live Junot Díaz Journey to Motherhood Dorsía Smith Silva vii latina/chicana mothering Learning the Hard Way Angie Cruz Mi Madre, Mi Hija y...»

«National Study on Domestic Violence against Women in Tonga NOFO ‘A KAINGA June 2012 i DISCLAIMER This report has been prepared by Dr. Henrica A.F.M. (Henriette) Jansen, Dr. Seu’ula Johansson-Fua, Betty Hafoka-Blake, and Gabriella Renee ‘Ilolahia. The views in the report are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Australian Government or of any other organisation or person. ii Copyright © Ma`a Fafine mo e Famili 2012 Ma`a Fafine mo e Famili Inc. MFF Building...»

«1 THE CARIBOO AND MONASHEE RANGES OF BRITISH COLUMBIA: AN ALPINIST’S GUIDE by EARLE R. WHIPPLE (2010) Even today, British Columbia, the most western province of Canada, is still a wilderness of mountains, valleys, glaciers, forest and plateau. The Columbia Mountains (Interior Ranges; containing the Cariboo, Monashee, Selkirk and Purcell Ranges) lie entirely within British Columbia, just west of the Canadian Rocky Mountains and the southern Alberta-British Columbia border. This Guide describes...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2017 www.abstract.dislib.info - Abstracts, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.