WWW.ABSTRACT.DISLIB.INFO
FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Abstracts, online materials
 
<< HOME
CONTACTS



Pages:     | 1 | 2 || 4 | 5 |

«Journal of Phonetics (2002) 30, 139–162 doi:10.1006/jpho.2002.0176 Available online at on The phonetics of phonological ...»

-- [ Page 3 ] --

Duration may also interact with voicing. During a fricative, pressure buildup behind the oral constriction equalizes transglottal pressure, making voicing more difficult. Thus, long duration voiced fricatives may have a stronger tendency to devoice. However, the connection is not an absolute one, as it is perfectly possible to maintain voicing during a long fricative. Though rare, voiced geminate fricatives are attested in the world’s languages (e.g., Italian). Note also that this dependence only predicts that long /z/ will devoice, not that a very long fricative is necessarily entirely voiceless. We feel that the dependence between acoustic properties measured in our study cannot wholly be explained by aerodynamic interdependence between our measures, and variation is to some extent under the active control of the talker.

Thus, there is room for more abstract levels of linguistic organization to influence the interrelation of our measures.

The phonetics of phonological speech errors

3. Categorical, gradient, and ungrammatical errors

In the previous section, it was demonstrated that the three dimensions of duration, frication amplitude, and percent voicing differentiate /s/ and /z/ for our participants.

Of these, the percent voicing measure most directly reflects the voicing contrast.

There is considerable overlap between /s/ and /z/ in the distribution of frication amplitude and duration, even among tokens that were perceived to be correctly produced. As a result, the effects of frication amplitude and duration are likely to be secondary in influencing the percept, and less definitive in determining when an error has occurred (Baum & Blumstein, 1987). In this section, we first investigate variation in percent voicing, and then consider the variation in frication amplitude and duration. Finally, we briefly discuss the other disfluent productions found in our corpus. Overall, the presence of these strange utterances and the considerable variability in production even for percent voicing supports the claim that many ungrammatical speech error outputs occur (Mowrey & MacKay, 1990).

3.1. Variation in percent voicing The percent voicing of all tokens for each participant is shown in Fig. 3. The data are grouped to illustrate productions that are usual and unusual for each participant. Both 0 and 100% voicing are given separately. The other groups are 0–5, 5–10, 10–30, 30–60, and 60–100%. Each panel of Fig. 3 shows the number of occurrences for one participant. Within each panel, the shaded bars indicate occurrences for intended /s/ and the clear bars indicate occurrences for intended /z/.

The data in Fig. 3 are summarized in Table I, where the aggregate number of occurrences for each percent voicing category for all participants is given for both /s/ and /z/.

Given that these tongue twisters were recorded in an experimental laboratory setting, we assume the participants were hyperarticulating and attempting to produce clear speech. Thus the the target percent voicing is likely to be 0% for /s/ and 100% for /z/. In normal speech, partial devoicing of /z/ results in productions that are voiceless in the middle, though these productions are usually still more than 60% voiced (Haggard, 1978; Smith, 1997). Fig. 3 and Table I show that many productions did not fall into the percent voicing groups that would normally be predicted for /s/ and /z/. Utterances where the percent voicing was between 5 and 30% are certainly anomalous for both /s/ and /z/. These productions with intermediate amounts of voicing provide evidence that gradient, noncategorical errors are made (Mowrey & MacKay, 1990).

Overall there are fewer cases of intermediate voicing for /s/ than for /z/.2 Among the utterances with intermediate voicing, /s/ also shows a clear pattern of variability.

As the percent voicing increases, fewer and fewer tokens of /s/ are found that have that degree of voicing. This is the pattern we might expect for phonetic variability if Participant 6 is a curious exception to the generalizations about the likelihood of gradient errors in /s/ and /z/. For participant 6, /s/ is more variable, and was overlapped with the following vowel (and the preceding vowel if there was one) a small amount in many utterances. On the other hand, /z/ for participant 6 is much less variable, with almost all instances realized with 100% voicing. Participant 6 is also atypical in the production of categorical errors, and does not follow the /s/ or /z/ pattern of the majority of the participants as discussed below.

150 S. A. Frisch and R. Wright Figure 3. Distribution of tokens among percent voicing groups for /s/ and /z/ for each participant.

–  –  –

0% voicing is intended. Productions that are farther away from the intended are relatively less likely, as they lie on the tail of the distribution. By contrast, the devoicing of /z/ was relatively common and does not clearly reflect degrees of variation away from an intended production of 100% voicing. Levels of voicing between 5 and 100% occur with relatively equal frequency and there are no apparent systematic patterns. It may be that, since the devoicing of /z/ is common in normal productions, the data here are mixture of normally devoiced /z/ and cases where /z/ is partially devoiced in error.

Fig. 3 and Table I also provide distributional evidence for categorical errors.





Across all participants, there are 18 cases where /s/ was produced with more than 60% voicing (out of 397 total). Compared to the five cases with 30–60% voicing and 12 cases with 10–30% voicing, the number of completely voiced tokens is relatively large. For the individual data of six of nine participants the number of tokens with more than 60% voicing was greater than the number of tokens with 10–60% voicing. This suggests that in addition to the peak in the distribution of /s/ at 0% voicing, there is a second peak in the distribution of /s/ at 100% voicing. We interpret this second peak to be the result of categorical changes from intended /s/ to [z].

There is also phonetic evidence that the tokens of /s/ with greater than 60% voicing are categorical errors. These tokens have shorter duration and lower frication amplitude than the typical /s/. In addition, these tokens have overlap between the frication noise and the onset of the formant structure of the following vowel that is typical of /z/ in our data. Finally, these fricatives have amplitude envelopes that gradually increase from the amplitude of the fricative toward the amplitude peak of the following vowel, which is also typical for /z/ in our data.

There are 56 cases where /z/ was produced with 0% voicing (out of 435 total).

The number of completely voiceless cases is larger than the number of cases with low levels of intermediate voicing (0–10%) for the individual data of seven of the nine participants. In about half of these cases, these also appear upon inspection to be categorical errors, with /z/ produced as [s]. In these cases, there is /s/-like duration and frication amplitude. There is a small positive VOT between the offset of /z/ and the onset of voicing and formant structure for the following vowel. There is also an abrupt decrease in frication amplitude of the /z/ followed by an abrupt rise in vowel amplitude to the vowel amplitude peak that is characteristic of /s/ in our data. However, there are other cases of 0% voicing that lack these additional /s/-like features where the result may be better transcribed as ½zŠ.

 One example of an apparent categorical intended /z/ to [s] error is given in Fig. 4.

The top panel of Fig. 4 shows [s] in the production of zap by participant 5. The bottom panel shows an error-free production of sap by the same participant. In both utterances, there is a relatively large amount of frication noise, and the offset of the fricative is complete before the onset of the following vowel begins.

An example of an error where intended /z/ is realized as ½zŠ is given in Fig. 5. The  top panel of Fig. 5 shows ½zŠ in the production of zap by participant 9. The bottom  panel of the figure shows an error-free production of sap by the same participant. In contrast with the categorical example above, the ½zŠ has a much lower frication  amplitude, and the frication noise offset is at about the same time as the vowel onset. So while there is no measurable voicing during the fricative, there is no delay 152 S. A. Frisch and R. Wright Figure 4. Example categorical error in the production of zap (top panel) and normal production of sap (bottom panel) for participant 5.

Figure 5. Example devoicing error in the production of zap (top panel) and normal production of zap (bottom panel) for participant 9.

in voice onset as there is with /s/. Thus, it appears that even though there is no voicing, this error is not a categorical change from /z/ to [s].

The variation in percent voicing suggests that more errors (whether gradient or categorical) were from /z/ toward [s] than from /s/ toward [z]. This pattern is expected, as /s/ is higher in frequency of occurrence than /z/ and in general lowfrequency items are replaced by high-frequency items in speech errors (Stemberger, 1983). However, it has been reported in the speech error literature that /s/ and /z/ errors are one of several cases where the normal frequency effect is reversed (Stemberger, 1991). Stemberger found that /s/ to [z] errors were more common than /z/ to [s] errors in a transcribed speech error experiment designed to examine asymmetries in segmental errors.

The phonetics of phonological speech errors Though the phonetic variability suggests that /z/ errors are more common than /s/ errors, variability in voicing in /z/ does not affect the perception of /z/ nearly as much as it affects the perception of /s/. Fig. 6 shows our judgement of the error rate based on our percept of each token. Tokens are aggregated into the same percent voicing groups as above, and the percent that were perceived as errors is plotted against the average percent voicing of tokens in the group. Our judgement of the percept was determined informally by consensus, based on repeated listening through headphones at a computer workstation. We found our level of agreement on the percept to be high. A token was considered to be an error if it was an /s/ that was not perceived as [s] or if it was a /z/ that was not perceived as [z]. While we did perceive some cases as ½zŠ, many cases that would be best described as ½zŠ   were not perceived to be anomalous. These cases were only identified as ½zŠ by visual  inspection of the waveform. In the perceptual data, only the cases of perceived ½zŠ  were counted as errors.

Fig. 6 shows a pattern of error detection that is strikingly similar to categorical perception with a boundary in the vicinity of 5% voicing (Liberman, 1997). Note that there is a heavy asymmetry in the perception of errors in /s/ and /z/ productions. While an /s/ with almost any voicing was perceived as [z], few cases of devoiced /z/ were perceived to be [s] or ½zŠ. Even when there was no voicing at all  in the /z/, it often sounded normal. Thus, while the production data suggest that there were more anomalies in the /z/ tokens than the /s/ tokens, the perception of this variation was heavily biased to detect /s/ errors but not /z/ errors. This perceptual asymmetry explains the apparent reversal of the frequency effect that was found by Stemberger (1991) and provides further evidence that speech error transcription is an unreliable method for examining the speech production process.

3.2. Variation in frication amplitude and duration Unusual variation in percent voicing reveals that there are many gradient errors in the production of /s/ and /z/ in our corpus. It is less clear how the dimensions of frication amplitude and duration might reveal gradient errors, since these dimensions are not fully contrastive. Even though the distributions of frication amplitude and

–  –  –

duration do not categorically differentiate /s/ from /z/, they do provide secondary cues to the voicing distinction (Cole & Cooper, 1975; Shadle, 1985). We have shown that tokens with 30% or more voicing were reliably perceived as [z]. Cases with less voicing were much less reliably categorized. Closer examination of the data reveal variation in frication amplitude and duration, in addition to voicing, affected the perception of errors. In particular, for tokens with small amounts of voicing, high frication amplitude and long duration were cues for /s/, while low frication amplitude and short duration were cues for /z/.

Table II shows mean frication amplitude and duration for /s/ and /z/ depending on whether they were perceived as errors or not. The top portion of the table presents aggregate data for tokens with 0–5% voicing, the middle portion presents aggregate data for tokens with 5–30% voicing, and the bottom portion presents aggregate date for tokens with 30–100% voicing. While very few /s/ with 0–5% voicing were perceived as errors, those that were appear to have lower frication amplitude and shorter duration than those that were not (for amplitude t(347)=1.7, p=0.09; for duration t(347)=1.6, p=0.06). For /z/ with 0–5% voicing, the pattern was similar. Tokens with high frication amplitude and long duration were perceived as [s], those with low frication amplitude and short duration were perceived as [z] (for amplitude t(62)=4.0, po0.01; for duration t(62)=2.5, po0.01). For /s/ and /z/ with 5–30% voicing, frication amplitude and duration again appear to have an effect on whether the tokens were perceived as errors or not, though the only statistically significant difference is for frication amplitude for /s/ (t(22)=2.9, po0.01). Finally, in cases of 30–100% voicing, there were no tokens that were not perceived as [z], so TABLE II. Mean frication amplitude and duration for low, intermediate, and high percent voicing groups as a function of intended segment and perceived error for all participants

–  –  –

it appears that variation in frication amplitude and duration are not sufficiently powerful cues to overwhelm the perceptual effect of periodicity.



Pages:     | 1 | 2 || 4 | 5 |


Similar works:

«AORTIC VALVE PERFORATION BY NOBLE 0. FOWLER, M.D., AND MORTON H. HAMBURGER, M.D., AND (by invitation) KEVIN E. BOVE, M.D. CINCINNATI Among patients with bacterial endocarditis whose infection has been eradicated, congestive heart failure is the leading cause of death or disability.1 Although myocarditis is a comnmon complication of bacterial endocarditis, increased valvular damage can usually be documented in patients who have congestive heart failure as a complication of bacterial...»

«The premier source of parts and accessories for mini lathes and mini mills. Mini Lathe User’s Guide from LittleMachineShop.com Copyright © 2002, LittleMachineShop.com All rights reserved. Some photos Copyright © 2002, Frank J. Hoose, Jr. All rights reserved. Frank J. Hoose Jr. of Mini-Lathe.com took many of the photographs in this document. Be sure to visit the Mini-Lathe.com Web site, which has a wealth of information about the mini lathe. LittleMachineShop.com...»

«12 Minimizing technological oversights: A marketing research perspective Jehoshua Eliashberg, Gary L. Lilien, and Vithala R. Rao I. Introduction... f the weight of invention or discovery is one, the weight to bring it to actual develi opment should be ten and the weight to produce nnd market it should be one hundred. Masru Ibuka President of Sony Despite increasingly experienced management, the majority of new products fail to achieve their anticipated level of success in the marketplace....»

«Market structure, financial intermediation and riskiness of banks:Evidence from Asia Pacific Wahyoe Soedarmono, Amine Tarazi To cite this version: Wahyoe Soedarmono, Amine Tarazi. Market structure, financial intermediation and riskiness of banks:Evidence from Asia Pacific. 2014. hal-00947575 HAL Id: hal-00947575 https://hal-unilim.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00947575 Submitted on 17 Feb 2014 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the...»

«N300 Wireless ADSL2+ Modem Router DGN2200v4 User Manual March 2013 202-11157-01 350 East Plumeria Drive San Jose, CA 95134 USA N300 Wireless ADSL2+ Modem Router DGN2200v4 Support Thank you for selecting NETGEAR products. After installing your device, locate the serial number on the label of your product and use it to register your product at https://my.netgear.com. You must register your product before you can use NETGEAR telephone support. NETGEAR recommends registering your product through...»

«BACKGROUND PAPER FOR THE WORLD DEVELOPMENT REPORT 2013 Labor Market Institutions: A Review of the Literature Gordon Betcherman University of Ottawa Abstract This paper reviews the findings of over 150 studies on the impacts of four types of labor market institutions: minimum wages, employment protection regulation, unions and collective bargaining, and mandated benefits. The review places particular emphasis on results from developing countries. Impacts studied are on living standards...»

«, o. 3 3 3 if July 2001 M.A. Minor Thesis INEQUALITIES IN SCHOOLS: Socio-Economic Background Or Culture, Method O f Curriculum Transmission And Language. Denise O ’Keeffe, B.A. Presented to the Department O f Sociology, National University O f Ireland, Maynooth, Co. Kildare In Partial Fulfillment O f The Masters degree In Sociology 2001.TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION CHAPTER TWO CRITICAL MULTICULTURALISM; GENERAL IDEAS ON RETHINKING EDUCATION CHAPTER THREE SOCIAL...»

«WILLIAM HUTTON & ANN PARTRIDGE WILLIAM HUTTON BORN: 1799, Scotland DIED: 1862 Wangoom, Vic. MARRIED: 8 May 1829, Hobart, Tas.ANN PARTRIDGE BAPTISED: 21 June 1812, Droitwich, Worcestershire DIED: 1847, Mt Rouse, Vic. ISSUE: (1) Isabella Anne (2) William George (3) Thomas David (4) Susanna Sarah (5) Mary Paul (6) James Charles (7) Lucy Eleanor (8) Alexander (9) Jane Charlotte (10) Henry Partridge 5 WILLIAM HUTTON & ANN PARTRIDGE 4 SCOTTISH FAMILY William Hutton was a Scot. His family has been...»

«Adventure Activity Standards (AAS) Guidelines for commercial and noncommercial Dependent Groups The Snow Sports AAS  Skiing –cross country & downhill  Snowboarding  Tobogganing  Snowshoeing  Snow tubing  Snow camping Published by the Outdoors Victoria Ltd PO Box 101 0 Templestowe 3106 Supported by the Victorian outdoor sector and the Victorian Government Disclaimer The information contained in this publication has been gathered through widespread sector consultation. All...»

«MEETING Cabinet DATE 16 February 2016 TITLE Overview of Gwynedd Council's Performance 2015-16 fields of Children and Young People, Care, the Welsh Language, Effective and Efficient Council and Financial Planning PURPOSE To accept and note the information in the report AUTHOR Councillor Dyfed Edwards CONTACT Geraint Owen, Head of Corporate Support Department OFFICER 1.0 Introduction 1.1 In accordance with the Council’s performance management system, an overview of the Council's performance in...»

«Unit 8: The Role of MPs and Parliamentary Staff Learning Objectives How Parliament Gets the Job Done After studying this unit, you should be able to:  Understand the differing roles which an MP is called upon to play in parliament;  Compare the MP’s responsibilities in these different roles;  Describe how the responsibilities can vary according to the expectations of the electorate that chooses an MP;  Discuss the ways in which parliamentary staff may be called upon to support MPs...»

«The IB Extended Essay DRAMARAMA? The Library, St. Andrew's College No, It’s Not Rocket Science Planning and research makes the process a lot easier!! The Library, St. Andrew's College What’s The Point Of The Seminar? Help you understand the EE process Point out some common mistakes Allow you to raise your concerns Answer your questions The Library, St. Andrew's College What is the IB EE? FORMAL, ACADEMIC ESSAY of approx. 4,000 words in which something is INVESTIGATED or explored There is a...»





 
<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2017 www.abstract.dislib.info - Abstracts, online materials

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.